Essay Foraging Public Lands

Minnesota’s Foraging Community: A Fork in the Trail

A couple weeks ago, I attended a listening session at the state capitol. It was an opportunity for members of the public to give testimony to the task force currently working to make recommendations around foraging rules/laws on state-owned lands. My takeaway?

This is gonna be messy. 

My follow-up conversation with Peter Martignacco, member of the task force and president of the Minnesota Mycological Society, did nothing to change my impression. In fact, the big picture only looked more and more jumbled. First, a little background. 

Minnesota Sustainable Foraging Task Force

This all started almost three years ago. As it happens, Peter was at the center of it. He was speaking informally with with one of the higher-ups at the Minnesota DNR Roundtable (which I plan to attend again next month). He asked, in light of everything the department had done for mountain bikers and ATV users, if there was any intention to develop resources for foragers. She essentially said no, but that they were thinking of making a change at state parks to limit foragers to a gallon’s worth of harvest. 

This became big news fast in the foraging community. Outside it, there were pieces in local newspapers, on the radio, and on national web outlets in the months that followed. Peter said he thinks that DNR official probably regrets having said anything. 

“Honestly, the DNR’s been a little bit kicking and screaming to get us to this point,” he said. “They have not supported the task force effort, and they have consistently insisted there was no opportunity to have stakeholders be involved in developing policy. Not really willing to talk about it.”

So, the state legislature intervened in a way, establishing the Minnesota Sustainable Foraging Task Force to gather information and present recommendations to the DNR and lawmakers by March. 

Now, I could reach out to somebody at DNR to get their take on this, but honestly, I don’t expect much. I contacted somebody in the parks division a couple years ago to inquire about the matter, and all she did was point me to the email list to watch for updates about state park rule changes. At this point, I think all they’d do is mention the task force, and that they’re waiting to hear the recommendations next year. 

First Steps

I told Peter that I could understand why the DNR might be a bit standoffish, in that there really isn’t any existing DNR infrastructure to support foraging. As far as I can tell, no single division is the obvious choice. It could fall under forestry, parks, fish and wildlife, or even something else. And considering how much process is required just to make a simple fishing or hunting rule change, establishing and building up a more robust set of laws around foraging, as well as resources and on-site amenities of any kind, would probably be an enormous undertaking. 

Plus, and possibly most importantly, I know of no new funding for it on the horizon.  

All the same, the task force is moving ahead as directed. In addition to their six overarching directives, their work is being influenced by that public input. Peter said it’s having a real influence on what they’re doing, though it seems to add complicating factors. 

“Every time you turn around, there’s things you never thought of or considered, and didn’t apply to you but may apply to somebody else,” he said. Considering every facet we touched on in our conversation, I’m not surprised. It seems like a where-do-we-even-start kind of situation.

However, one of the things that keeps coming up in comments is the desire for education. People want to know more about what they’re doing and how to do it. They want to know how to do it ethically and sustainably, and stay inside the boundaries of what’s reasonable for the environment and other users.

Peter and I agreed it sounds very much like hunting and fishing, and everything we’ve been doing in that community for over a hundred years. You know, conservation. 

Minnesota State Parks Foraging Bag Limits

As I wrote in my most recent column for the Mankato Free Press, the education part should be at the forefront of whatever the DNR does for foraging. Without it, there’s no reasonable expectation for moving forward with more rules, or having people understand and abide by them. 

It’s funny to think this all started with mention of a rule change to establish a limit, because the task force is probably far from making recommendations around limits. Nobody probably cares what I think, but I would not hate to see foraging bag limits in state parks. 

Opponents will say there is no evidence that foraging is having a detrimental effect, and that’s true. For now. There’s probably no evidence one way or another. And with time, evidence might show it’s benign. However, I’m concerned that foraging traffic—inherently an off-trail activity—could still do damage. Many Minnesota state parks encompass rare and/or fragile habitats, the way Scientific and Natural Areas (SNAs) do. Impacts to sensitive plant communities or erodible soils are a genuine concern (or should be). 

Again, maybe that will never be a problem. But environmental damage isn’t the only reason rules are written. Impacts to other users could, and probably should, be taken into account. 

On an anecdotal level, I’ve observed on social media that foragers gravitate toward state parks. Especially urban folks. It’s public land they know about and understand (as opposed to state forests or WMAs). I personally have encountered other foragers in state parks, as well as evidence that they were there before me. Like bushes picked clean of ripe berries, or cut mushroom stems on the ground. That has almost never happened to me on other types of public land. 

If bag limits in state parks encourage people to disperse across the landscape onto other land types, that can only be a good thing for foragers and the environment alike. 

Rules, Rules, Rules

Now, one thing the foraging community would like to see is more uniform rules for foraging across parcel types (state park, state forest, etc.). In my opinion, that’s not practical. 

Where it comes to allowed activities and uses, I think of our state lands as being on a spectrum. The least restrictive are the state forests, where we can do things like forage, hunt, gather firewood and other forest products, and camp almost anywhere. On the other end of the spectrum are the SNAs, where a person can do little but observe nature (with a handful of exceptions). In the middle are WMAs and state parks, with parks being next to SNAs on the spectrum. I just don’t see how foraging could find a one-size-fits-all place across all those lands types. 

In addition to uniform rules not being practical, I’d say that isn’t necessary. If foragers are to step onto an equal plane in the conservation world—and they absolutely should—they can put their big kid pants on and rise to the occasion. In circles of conservation and on our public lands, the onus is on the user to know what the law is. Hunters and anglers have whole booklets of rules they need to follow. Those rules are literally always changing, with many specific to single lakes or other locations. It’s part and parcel of the outdoor life. 

Sure, it is complicated. But the growth of the foraging community has kind of forced itself into this place. 

Foragers Should Be Conservation-Minded

How do we sort this all out? Education is the beginning. Hopefully that will be one of the task force’s main recommendations. And again, hopefully, that is something the DNR will be willing to take part in.

Then, the foraging community should develop resources collectively. Raise money, if that’s what it takes. Get together and advocate for what matters, then work with the DNR. That is, not against it. Educate and mentor each other. Take care of the land, genuinely. If that means you don’t always get everything you want, then you might be doing it right.

Look to longstanding conservation organizations and study how they’ve accomplished what they have. They’ll have a lot to offer. And they’ll welcome foragers as equal partners in conservation. That is, if foragers desire to be more than burs hitching a ride through the woods. 

Told you it would be messy. 

One Comment

  1. Peter Martignacco

    Thanks Roy for joining this conversation. As you point out this has many facets. I agree that we need to look beyond just the act of collecting for impacts and I have met no one who does not want to protect fragile ecosystems in State Parks or on any public land. When asked by the Task Force the DNR had little to put forward regarding impacts that have been identified but the concerns you put forward are valid and I can’t be more clear in that we are referring to public land and all users, and their interests should be respected. I also want readers to understand that the state park bag limit proposals were not developed with public awareness and the bag limit that was proposed was intended to be a functional ban on foraging in state parks. (read the current state park website guidelines on harvesting berries and mushrooms) Bag limits on personal foraging may be appropriate but regardless the amounts should reflect the purpose of foraging food which often includes preservation. When we talk about a rule framework it is referring to consistent structure not it being universal across land types. Yes, many urban residents gravitate to state parks. They provide access that does not require long travel and infrastructure, trails, restrooms and safety from getting lost and in being vulnerable due to isolation. This is a family friendly environment to explore these connections to nature. As people become more experienced, they often will seek out less traveled locations. This is a role the DNR can fill in identifying areas and opportunities to explore. Foragers need to actively participate with conservation partners as should many others who have depended on hunters and fisherman for over a century to carry the torch. I look forward speaking and working with others as we wrestle with these questions regarding access and responsiblity. e

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*